Mekkah said:Alive (24)
Altair
Amelia
Aura Guardian
Bass
Coronis
Engineer Pikachu
Fishin
Fishy
Flamestrike
Genny
Gmax
Lord Jesseus
Mr.378
RB Golbat
Staraptor Call
THE IRON KENYAN
Veedrock
billymills
evan
moot
polelover44
porygon3
reyscarface
shade
Yeah I pretty much said "I have no important flavor text" I don't understand why you keep mentioning that as a way to support your lynch against me, if you could explain it that would be great.I can tell you right now that his PM will have unconvincing flavor appeal and a village win condition. Is it really useful to wait a whole day to gain nothing?
Here you suggest that you should be inspected, twice.If any inspector wants to choose me this cycle that would be fine. I can post my role PM next cycle if needed.
I might idle this cycle so I don't hit anyone trying to clean me.
Sure, you could. You could also have fucked up. Everyone does it.Ok guys yeah I know it does sound like a Monster character and a mafia role. But if I was mafia, and I've said this to a few people already, don't you think I would come up with a better role to false claim? Don't you think I would figure out a better character to claim? And that's if Mekkah didn't even give the mafias false claim material, which would surprise me.
Uhh, yea. That's probably the most direct you could be.If everyone thinks I am mafia then that's even more reason to inspect me. As far as I know, I am not a miller.
You'd have a perfectly good reason for claiming such, read Mekkah's third post.Sure I could have made up something different but then someone inspects me and the result doesn't match up with my claim at all, and I would seem even more suspicious that way.
Well in Pokemon Mafia one of the mafias had a role that could make a player appear to be an NPC if inspected, and I think he used it on his team every time (someone correct me if I'm wrong).
If that's actually your role, then you really should have changed your flavor around a bit. There is no way I'm letting a monster that may or may not exist lead me against the Monsters that May or May Not Exist (note capitals).Just to clarify, I am not saying the inspector has to inspect me. Obviously it is up to him, and if he wants to pick someone else he can do that. All I said was (real quote) "If any inspector wants to choose me this cycle that would be fine. I can post my role PM next cycle if needed." Mostly because there is no way to prove my role (well no good way), I thought trying to get some kind of proof would be useful. And I'm not about to go random targeting with this. Again I can post my PM next cycle, I doubt that will help since everyone will still assume I am a mole but whatever.
First, this isn't random lynching. You claimed a terrible character with a terrible role. Second random inspecting is not bad because it cleans a person or incriminates a person. Most importantly, random inspecting gives an element of surprise. A mafia doesn't know which person to block (presumably one or more inspect-blocking roles exist in this game). Lynching a person is a more definitive version of cleaning people, inspecting works better if it's a surprise. It's rare (but not impossible) to stop a lynch.Also you can say "why waste an inspection on p3 when we can random target and try to get a mafia". However if "random lynching is bad because there's a higher chance of hitting a villager", you also MUST believe "random inspecting is bad because there's a higher chance of hitting a villager". So don't act like cleaning one suspicious person is any worse than cleaning a different random person. I'm fine with whatever but honestly that is just stupid.
And if porygon3 is a mole? We just wasted an entire cycle, gave the mafia a cycle to kill us off, and porygon3 woulda just gotten a ton of information from claims... I think we should just try and get someone this cycle, and have the inspector clean whoever is trying to lead the village, like Veedrock, but if we are to claim early, like Veedrock suggested, I think the entire role, alignment, and flavor isn't really necessary. Maybe just role and win condition? (e.g. i can redirect a night kill to someone else, and i win if the village wins. (that's not mine))Just a quick FYI: That IRC quote is real. I still am in the "wait" camp, but I could be convinced, I guess. I will wait, though. I still have time.
[blah blah blah]
At that point I was assuming someone would want to inspect me, to clean the (then) only person doing anything.Here you suggest that you should be inspected, twice.
If I'm going to publically claim and try to lead a village, if I was mafia, I wouldn't "fuck up" like that. "Oops I accidently forgot to change my character name/ability when I claimed villager" is not exactly an excuse you would hear too often.Sure, you could. You could also have fucked up. Everyone does it.
Again, I was assuming everyone would want to and was trying to explain my reasoning for what I was suggesting. Something you still have not done for the whole flavor text thing.Uhh, yea. That's probably the most direct you could be.
Yeah I'll just make up some completely different role, then IF I get inspected and the results don't match up with my claim AT ALL I bet nobody would find that suspicious !! Also good job taking that last part out of context, way to be relevant.You'd have a perfectly good reason for claiming such, read Mekkah's third post.
Saying that a mafia had a role like this in the past isn't the best way of cleaning yourself, but whatever floats your boat.
That's not changing my flavor a bit, that's completely changing my role, going back to what I said above.If that's actually your role, then you really should have changed your flavor around a bit. There is no way I'm letting a monster that may or may not exist lead me against the Monsters that May or May Not Exist (note capitals).
Your word choice indicates that you would call someone declaring themself a poodle when they are actually a dragon, as long as they do not change their ability, would not be suspicious. I would disagree. I get the sense that if pory3 is mafia, then he is a scapegoat. for billymills to gain our trust. I merely cast suspicions, no votes yet.I meant make up a completely different character. I couldn't care if you fake your character in order to come up with a reasonable claim, if your role stays the same.
No, it wouldn't be suspicious, because it'd still say you're a villager, which is more than I believe right now =/