Anyways ima say it again. The metagame is only 3 teams. Sand rain or stall or a mix of the 3. Its boring to play. We need another suspect test to get rid of drizzle and the sand abusers. Is that better?
Erm... well you did say there was stall too but pretty much you did say what he claimed you did.And i didn't say that there was only sand and rain.
Um, if some people can't stand rain and sand, what's wrong with them going back to 4th gen? That's the whole point of maintaining a 4th gen metagame, isn't it? That way, people who dislike the changes can always go back if they want.If voters/noms dont do my suggestions then 5th gen will get old very fast any every team will be a sand or rain team even more than now. Everyone will go back to 4th gen. You need only slight gaming experience to predict this.
There isn't a justifiable reason for banning just Sand Veil. Not right now.The point about the percentage is that people often deem it negligible, that it causes an occasional miss, when it's actually a much bigger factor than that.
My favorite argument from you (BAN ME PLEASE) wanting to keep Sand Veil is when you tell people to "stop bitching". Bitching about it is understandable when you're essentially being cheated out of a win each time. Just go to Thorhammer if you want some intellectual shit justifying it.
I don't need a whole lot of gaming experience to know that there is people like you in every competitive community for every competitive game imaginable. You'll complain, whine about the circumstances, and if possible, demand things be changed. I've seen it before, and I see it all the time. Not just here.If voters/noms dont do my suggestions then 5th gen will get old very fast any every team will be a sand or rain team even more than now. Everyone will go back to 4th gen. You need only slight gaming experience to predict this.
Whats hard to understand? All im saying is that rain and sand are very very common. In the long run if no bans happen the entire metagame will be only rain and sand. People are so quick to attack me but cant even understand whats right in their face.Umm
What O_O
Curtains I don't understand what you're saying. Your posts are contradictory and most don't make any sense. What Berserker said was harsh, but if you really think that the only viable teams are Rain and Sand then you really don't know a whole lot about the metagame.
Whats hard to understand? All im saying is that rain and sand are very very common. In the long run if no bans happen the entire metagame will be only rain and sand. People are so quick to attack me but cant even understand whats right in their face.
Its kind of hard to succeed when you have specs hydro pumps and specs hurricanes coming at you. Or sub dance garchomps sweeping off a miss. How about a meta-game based on skill rather than off of boosted attacks with no set up or penalty i.e drizzle. Why would you not use a rain or sand team when these things look so appealing?If your posts weren't so fucking convulted, then maybe we could stop getting confused, but you clearly don't want to stop that. And how the hell would the metagame be only Sand and Rain if no bans occur? People will get creative and find ways to succeed against those weather teams.
Its kind of hard to succeed when you have specs hydro pumps and specs hurricanes coming at you. Or sub dance garchomps sweeping off a miss. How about a meta-game based on skill rather than off of boosted attacks with no set up or penalty i.e drizzle. Why would you not use a rain or sand team when these things look so appealing?
Mind point out those places because I don't seem to notice where anyone posting ATM is putting words into your mouth.And my post are not convoluted. Just read carefully and not let my nickname get in the way of your comprehension. Every post thus far people have put words in my mouth.
It seemed fine, mostly because Gen 3 didn't have Garchomp, and in Gen 4, Garchomp was uber. And before Garchomp was uber, people recognized that it wasn't fine.Do we need to deal with sand veil? If been fine the past 2 gens, and actually has a challanger now, rain.
If skill to you is abusing sand veil and spaming hydro pump/waterfall/hurricane in rain then maybe your the dumbass. I use a non weather team and got to top 60-50 or something. I remember beating you actually skillfully (got the logs). Then everyone i played after abused garchomp. Every single battle was garchomp subbing and sd and me missing. Im not trying to fight or insult anyone. Thats against the rules. Im just saying the metagame is going in the wrong direction with silly non decisive bans the first 3 test.
why reply to me if you don't want me to discuss? Your a gluten for punishment. Im discussing not bitching. I bitched in my first post that the mod deleted. Im discussing now. Can you comprehend what i am saying. Is that convoluted to you? Discussing it gets other peoples opinions on it. Isnt that what this thread is for? If you cant come up with quality results to back up your claims don't call anyone a dumbass.Well whoop dee fucking doo for you. You beat me, and what exactly is that supposed to accomplish? I lose like 60% of my battles everytime I play, so 1 loss doesn't affect me. And good for you for getting a good ranking with a non-weather team. And if think that the metagame is going in the wrong direction, get voting rights and try and change it instead of bitching about it.
But if the problem only exists with Garchomp, shouldn't it be solved by banning garchomp?It seemed fine, mostly because Gen 3 didn't have Garchomp, and in Gen 4, Garchomp was uber. And before Garchomp was uber, people recognized that it wasn't fine.
However, that doesn't mean it was ever fine, just that it was thought to be fine. Garchomp illustrates a problem that was always there. Furthermore, we didn't have a good way of dealing with it, so even when people complained (which happened often enough), we couldn't do anything about it. Now, we do.
who said anything about banning Sand Veil. I just made a post saying why its pointless. Lets face it, Garchomp is the only thing that is *maybe* broken with Sand Veil. You don't see people bitching about Sand Veil Gliscor, its only Garchomp mainly cause of its high speed, bulk, Swords Dance and Substitute effectivally put you in a do or die situation where if you miss, Garchomp gets a free Swords Dance. If it picks up another Swords Dance and also grabs a Substitute its basically gg. Therefore since it is only Garchomp which people are fussed about then it is only Garchomp which would (hypothetically) be banned. Similar to Speed Boost Blaziken. Speed boost as an ability is not broken, the ability was only broken on Blaziken, hence we banned Blaziken.Sand Veil can only be reasonably banned through Evasion Clause.
There are currently no method to ban Pokemon through Clauses, AKA, for reasons other than being overpowered in the tier.
However, no one's going to believe that Garchomp, Sand Veil or not, is actually overpowered.
Thus, Garchomp can't be banned with our current suspect testing system (under the justification of merely being luck-based), so the only way is to use a Clause to target Sand Veil, since Abilities have much fewer restrictions on how they can be banned.
Sandstorm (for better or worse) is common in this metagame and thanks to Swords Dance and Substitute Garchomp can abuse Sand Veil to get past its counters. Gliscor is OHKOed at +4 which is damn easy to do when EQ can only break Chomps Subs (and it can miss) and Ice Fang is the only thing that will really 2KO Garchomp (and if it has Yache your screwed). Not to mention its very easy for Garchomp to set up. Rotom W for example, is pretty much set up fodder as Hydro Pump will pretty much miss at least once. Ferrothorn is p much in the same boat. In addition very few things out speed Chomp that can also take an Outrage or Earthquake. and anyways, Chomp always has the option of switching out of an unfavourable match-up and coming back later in the game for more devastation.A Pokémon is uber if, in common battle conditions, it is capable of sweeping through a significant portion of teams in the metagame with little effort.
In that case why not ban STAB moves on Kyogre? Or Air Slash and Seed Flare on Shaymin S? Banning Substitute and Swords Dance on Garchomp is far too specialised as well as opening up a whole new can of worms. Also as I stated above -_-I'm not a regular poster on Smogon so forgive me if this suggestion is a little stupid, but if the only issue with Garchomp (as I don't think it is broken this gen either) is sand veil abuse, wouldn't it be better to ban the combination of sand veil garchomp and sand stream rather than Garchomp entirely? Or maybe substitue and swords dance on the same set, since it isn't Garchomp's fault Tyranitar is everywhere.
There's so many major threats this gen of Pokemon that banning Garchomp based on sand weather conditions alone seems a little unfair and more like an easy way out of dealing with Garchomp's in general, but as I said I haven't been a Smogon user long so sorry if this post is deemed stupid.
Alot of people here probably use TTar/Exca on all of their balanced teams and therefore are biased, but I think that'd be decent to try out for a while.Ohnoitsononokusu, it's just that getting into complex bans on particular pokemon gets to be a real headache to follow. It's not a bad suggestion, but it's just working within reason. If specific rules about moveset restrictions were made on particular pokemon, then we'd have a LOT of potential new restrictions to weed through.
And I saw a post earlier in the thread that really made me wonder...
What if we just banned all auto-weather? No Hippos, No TTars, No Toeds, No Foxes, No Yetis, and obviously no uber weathers. I realize this seems extreme, but is it really?
Rather than make the complex ban of Drizzle+Swift Swim, why not just ban Drizzle? Instead of banning Chomp for Sandstorm abuse, why not just ban Sand Stream? A metagame without auto-weather wouldn't be the end of the world. It seems like a semi-lazy ban, but to be honest, I just think it'd work. You don't even need to ban Toed and Ninetales, just the auto-weather ability. And with DW abilities out, pokemon that originally only had Auto-weather would be spared and could stay in the metagame through these means. No more DW tiers separate from regular tiers. Just remove auto-weather entirely.
Crazy, I know. But would it really be all that bad? Seriously. Would it?