to clarify, I permasubbed for sargeant "four leaf" yohoe and we were both plat 2/3 with plenty of ranked games last season. SV was plat 4 (5?) and so was Eo.
but I agree that combining premades with non-premade teams is kind of silly. our team was objectively stacked from an elo standpoint. I'd be down for both a one-day feedfest or a longer, similarly formatted tournament. might be hard to get lots of people to commit to the same day for the former idea (although it's sort of like SPL draft so maybe it would work).
sooner rather than later!