Both are amazing across the generations and capable of taking each tier.
In RBY, I favor SoulWind 55/45. I consider him to quietly one of the best RBY players on Smogon. His results in RBY cup in recent years are second-to-none. ABR understands the tier at a very high level though, so it should be close.
In GSC, i favor ABR 70/30. He has an amazing grasp on the tier and I feel like it is SoulWind's weakest metagame. ABR should be able to get a leg up in the teambuilder and he is more experienced making critical decisions in this format in the game.
In ADV, I favor ABR 60/40. He has a good grasp on ADV (impressive showings in tours like Callous Cup showing this) as well and I think he genuinely gets how to build in this generation. SoulWind's ADV is solid, but I view it as inferior to his 1/4/5. I think this one can be close, but gotta give ABR the edge.
In DPP, I favor SoulWind 65/35. With his DPP cup win and overall dominance in this generation recently, I think SoulWind has crept into the top DPP player conversation. His strength here has to be how he pilots teams. He seldom misplays and often has a great knowledge of what to expect. It comes to him very naturally and this has especially been the case recently.
In BW, I favor SoulWind 60/40. He has more experience than anyone and he has won more than everyone here. SoulWind'sBW dominance is impressive. ABR is no slouch in BW and has won this match-up before, but it is still going to be uphill I believe.
I favor SW in 3/5 tiers, but if you do the math it equates to a virtual 50/50 due to the weights of favoritism. Both of these guys are great and deserving winners, good luck
In RBY, I favor SoulWind 55/45. I consider him to quietly one of the best RBY players on Smogon. His results in RBY cup in recent years are second-to-none. ABR understands the tier at a very high level though, so it should be close.
In GSC, i favor ABR 70/30. He has an amazing grasp on the tier and I feel like it is SoulWind's weakest metagame. ABR should be able to get a leg up in the teambuilder and he is more experienced making critical decisions in this format in the game.
In ADV, I favor ABR 60/40. He has a good grasp on ADV (impressive showings in tours like Callous Cup showing this) as well and I think he genuinely gets how to build in this generation. SoulWind's ADV is solid, but I view it as inferior to his 1/4/5. I think this one can be close, but gotta give ABR the edge.
In DPP, I favor SoulWind 65/35. With his DPP cup win and overall dominance in this generation recently, I think SoulWind has crept into the top DPP player conversation. His strength here has to be how he pilots teams. He seldom misplays and often has a great knowledge of what to expect. It comes to him very naturally and this has especially been the case recently.
In BW, I favor SoulWind 60/40. He has more experience than anyone and he has won more than everyone here. SoulWind'sBW dominance is impressive. ABR is no slouch in BW and has won this match-up before, but it is still going to be uphill I believe.
I favor SW in 3/5 tiers, but if you do the math it equates to a virtual 50/50 due to the weights of favoritism. Both of these guys are great and deserving winners, good luck