Oh, I wasn't accusing anyone of deleting posts; I mean, I always use Quick Reply, and before if I accidentally clicked a link in the middle of writing the post and then hit back my post would be there. It's just a browser thing.
"I already told you I created the tier lists on my own. Nobody helped me with it. I have shown the list to several people while I was in the process of updating it."
Yep, I heard you, and the people you showed it to are the people I was referring to. Actually, now that you have made those changes, never mind this question...
And, thank you for making those changes... At this point, almost every Pokemon (excepting the 3 I'm about to argue for) you have listed now is in the right order (in a sense) as I see it, though I still believe your borderline tier is too extensive. Earlier you said borderlines can't compete with standards (in more or less words), and as I said, I very much disagree with this.
Here's what I'd also like to argue:
"Mr. Mime and Moltres, while owning UU with their great 278 speeds and awesome specials, can't really do a thing to Chansey and Alakazam / Eggy (Mime) or Alakazam / Starmie (Moltres). That's why they're considered by many to be "not good enough for standard but too good for UU". Oh, this also applies to a lesser extent to Tentacruel (great 298 speed, awesome special) which is walled by Starmie/Alakazam (with /very/ good support it might be able to Wrap its way to effectiveness, but good, accurate partial trapping doesn't make something BL..)."
Can you respond to this?
Also, I never elaborated on Hypno, but it's a complex issue and it's late so I won't do that quite yet... maybe tomorrow. With Hypno in mind, it seems you've just shifted the standards of both your tiers (standard and borderline) down a bit, actually.
Before I close this post, I want to say that I believe that a system in which multiple people are allowed to make changes to the official Smogon tiers would be more fair. Unless you want to set yourself as the only person who can rationally/fairly respond to criticism, I would say you should ask another major RBY'er and Smogon member, such as Hipmonlee, Lesm46, Vineon, Roy, or Fuzion (some of these may not have SCMS access though, I guess). ...The main problem you may have with this, as I know, is that for several of these RBY'ers, you disagree with them on everything and/or think that that they have a grudge against you. However, I still think that someone--an active, experienced, and respected RBY'er, who is familiar with the modern metagame--should share this responsibility, because otherwise it's the same as indicating you are the only experienced RBY'er you can trust to be honorable/judicious, which is... I dunno, like setting yourself up as a jealous eccentric. Maybe I can just try to argue a few other things and get these tiers in a position where they wouldn't differ much from most of those people's current opinions, however...
Edit: Also, will these tiers be changing the rules of the UU tourney that's already in progress?