NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon NOCfia DX

[Lrr]

That gives exactly zero weight towards caffeine being town. If caffeine is scum he would know it was dopog

 

[Lrr]

What makes more sense: the last scum is a 1x ninja with an extra kill or that it's just caffeine?

 

[Haruno]

Or caffeine is just one shot role cop/blocker and just role blocked me and blamed dopog .-. shrug

 

[Haruno]

What makes more sense: the last scum is a 1x ninja with an extra kill or that it's just caffeine?

These two aren't mutually exclusive since caffeine and sria's claims both give a different thing.

Caffeine gives them ninja
sria claimed the extra kill.

Only one is scum.

 

[Panic Station]

That gives exactly zero weight towards caffeine being town. If caffeine is scum he would know it was dopog

The problem that I have with that is it's too basic for Caff's meta. I;ve seen him play more "embrace the chaos" in antiTown roles before, and this is more like his "this are my results and if something's fucky hopefully it's not me screwing up" is Towny PR play for him.

Or caffeine is just one shot role cop/blocker and just role blocked me and blamed dopog .-. shrug

This is kinda what I'm getting at here, except I'm down with the world where it's this plus scum!Caff says hos action failed to and one of them must be JK and one must be scum RB BUT WHICH ONE HMMMMM?

 

[Lrr]

These two aren't mutually exclusive since caffeine and sria's claims both give a different thing.

Caffeine gives them ninja
sria claimed the extra kill.

Only one is scum.

If you believe schia is scum, that means caffeine is right about the ninja

 

[Haruno]

Yeah, well we can lynch caffeine since it solves discrepancies I would imagine. If the ninja thing is complete bullshit, then Panic and Mega both become confirmed town.

 

[Lrr]

The problem that I have with that is it's too basic for Caff's meta. I;ve seen him play more "embrace the chaos" in antiTown roles before, and this is more like his "this are my results and if something's fucky hopefully it's not me screwing up" is Towny PR play for him.



This is kinda what I'm getting at here, except I'm down with the world where it's this plus scum!Caff says hos action failed to and one of them must be JK and one must be scum RB BUT WHICH ONE HMMMMM?

Caffeine isn't even trying to scumhunt and you think it's town on meta? This behavior is easy to replicate. Shit, go look at his vote record, he was happy to sheep m2h

 

[Haruno]

The problem that I have with that is it's too basic for Caff's meta. I;ve seen him play more "embrace the chaos" in antiTown roles before, and this is more like his "this are my results and if something's fucky hopefully it's not me screwing up" is Towny PR play for him.



This is kinda what I'm getting at here, except I'm down with the world where it's this plus scum!Caff says hos action failed to and one of them must be JK and one must be scum RB BUT WHICH ONE HMMMMM?

I absolutely hate relying on meta to play lol

 

[Panic Station]

Lemme phrase that batter

This is kinda what I'm getting at here, except the scum!Caff I'm familiar with says his action failed too and one of them must be JK'd and one must be RB'd by scum... BUT WHICH ONE HMMMMM?

 

[Lrr]

Keep in mind caffeine's given reason for trying to wagon mega on d2 was he reassessed his reads, so he's at least claiming to think about the game

 

[Haruno]

Also reminder that caffeine saw a BG and a tracker claim and went, "SHIT, the two PR must be scum instead of the countless VT claims we had! LYNCH HARUNO!"

 

[Panic Station]

I absolutely hate relying on meta to play lol

I'm gonna disagree with you becuase if I didn't religiously use meta as a hunting tool Clar might be in the game still.

 

[Haruno]

I'm gonna disagree with you becuase if I didn't religiously use meta as a hunting tool Clar might be in the game still.

Just look at post 1155 and onwards and see how fucking horrible it looks.

 

[Haruno]

Also reminder that he casually went, "I want m2h to claim rn" and m2h miraculously did claim soon after! Then we realized that he was scum due to a discrepancy in claims and that was only to a delayed claim from dopog.

 

[Lrr]

Reminder that when it came down to it, m2h tried to wagon mega over the guy he had been death tunneling all phase. Why does scum m2h not push for a caffeine lynch if he's town?

 

[Schiavetto]

Now we're cooking

 

[Haruno]

Also 1540 with M2h going from the non existent wagon of mega, and then caffeine within literally seconds going along with it.

 

[Lrr]

Now we're cooking

I reread day 3 but my post was ignored :(

Day 2 knowing m2h is scum makes caffeine look really bad

 

[Haruno]

ALSO post 1642 where pretty much right after day 3 started, after some misc conversation, caffeine immediately asked about the vig. Quite odd how he thought it was a vig instead of a scum extra kill.

 

[Lrr]

Like, people thought the zaroco vig is unbelievable but schia ended the day with her vote on him because she missed end of day. It was a weird shot for scum and several people commented on it. I even speculated that we had a vig, it was that weird,

 

[Haruno]

Yeah okay. So we're just going for Caffeine lynch today, and then right after proceed onwards to Schia in a worst case scenario where Caffeine doesn't flip scum.

 

[Haruno]

What should we do with night actions then? Needless to say, I target schia 100%, if schia is scum, she would have to kill me tonight otherwise it would immediately make it clear that she's guilty.

 

[Haruno]

Also Spiderz I see you :eyes: join the next mafia game. ty

 

[Panic Station]

Yeah, okay. Half of this was me trying to sort through my own thoughts with a head full of adhd. I've got no objections after that breakdown you and Paper did, and I'm not worried rn.

Let's just go for it and see what happens.