Both have been fixed.
Erect is not falling from use, however.
Erect is not falling from use, however.
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
Data ASB Feedback & Game Issues Thread - Mk II
- Thread starter Dogfish44
- Start date
- Status
If this worked for the Battle Tower, maybe a queue will work here too...
List of things that need to be discussed on proper topic, implemented directly or shot down officially:
- Moon Stone
- Approver Policy
- Water Stone
- Pursuit vs Self Switch Inducing Moves
- Perish Song and Payout
- Yawn and Soundproof
- Update Crit Mechanisms to Gen VI
- HP
- Weight Moves
- Rewards for Winning
- Wish EN Formula
feel free to shoot all of them down, as long as something is decided and these subjects aren't lost in the chaotic realm that is this topic.
List of things that need to be discussed on proper topic, implemented directly or shot down officially:
- Moon Stone
- Approver Policy
- Water Stone
- Pursuit vs Self Switch Inducing Moves
- Perish Song and Payout
- Yawn and Soundproof
- Update Crit Mechanisms to Gen VI
- HP
- Weight Moves
- Rewards for Winning
- Wish EN Formula
feel free to shoot all of them down, as long as something is decided and these subjects aren't lost in the chaotic realm that is this topic.
Ty secretary frosty
- Moon Stone
Send to straight vote regarding additional effect of Moonlight, removing current alternative effect regarding recoil
- Approver Policy
This has effectively been resolved, IAR and akela have been established as the new head approvers recently so all related policy can be run through them. If Its_A_Random or akela feel a discussion thread is necessary then that's at their discretion
- Water Stone
Tempted to stop this for buff-culture reasons but I think a discussion thread could be worthwhile. Send to discussion.
- Pursuit vs Self Switch Inducing Moves
I'm making the ruling here that only the switching effect will be negated. akela, this was your proposal, make whatever change you feel is appropriate.
- Perish Song and Payout
Ruling. Not a chance for counterfarming. As always, KOC goes to the last Pokemon to deal damage, even under Perish Song. If a given Pokemon was never attacked, it goes to the Perish Song user. If a Pokemon exhausts itself without ever being attacked than the KOC is lost.
- Yawn and Soundproof
Ruling: the line "This move will fail if the opponent cannot hear the user" will be edited to reflect "If the Pokemon is unable to witness the Yawn, like if it is asleep, the move fails; a Pokemon being ordered to look away does not make it fail." This is based on the logic that irl hearing a Yawn is not a trigger (usually) for your own Yawn, but seeing a Yawn almost always is.
EDIT: Seems this was already resolved in exactly the manner I have described
- Update Crit Mechanisms to Gen VI
Dogfish44 go ahead. As of dogfish's post in implementation, crit mechanics will be updated to gen 6
- HP
This will be brought up for discussion in a thread that is being prepared by the moderation team.
- Weight Moves
see above
- Rewards for Winning
reeeeally dislike this proposal but it merits discussion. Birkal, mind taking the lead on this one?
- Wish EN Formula
Received some opposition, some support. Discussion over formula and potential vote will occur. Discussion thread.
Also just as a heads up we'll be closing this thread in the next few days in lieu of a new thread that will take this one's place for a while, before opening mk 3 of this thread.
So if you've got any complicated proposals in the wings, best to sit on them for a bit.
Also <3 you Frosty, this was literally perfect.
- Moon Stone
Send to straight vote regarding additional effect of Moonlight, removing current alternative effect regarding recoil
- Approver Policy
This has effectively been resolved, IAR and akela have been established as the new head approvers recently so all related policy can be run through them. If Its_A_Random or akela feel a discussion thread is necessary then that's at their discretion
- Water Stone
Tempted to stop this for buff-culture reasons but I think a discussion thread could be worthwhile. Send to discussion.
- Pursuit vs Self Switch Inducing Moves
I'm making the ruling here that only the switching effect will be negated. akela, this was your proposal, make whatever change you feel is appropriate.
- Perish Song and Payout
Ruling. Not a chance for counterfarming. As always, KOC goes to the last Pokemon to deal damage, even under Perish Song. If a given Pokemon was never attacked, it goes to the Perish Song user. If a Pokemon exhausts itself without ever being attacked than the KOC is lost.
- Yawn and Soundproof
Ruling: the line "This move will fail if the opponent cannot hear the user" will be edited to reflect "If the Pokemon is unable to witness the Yawn, like if it is asleep, the move fails; a Pokemon being ordered to look away does not make it fail." This is based on the logic that irl hearing a Yawn is not a trigger (usually) for your own Yawn, but seeing a Yawn almost always is.
EDIT: Seems this was already resolved in exactly the manner I have described
- Update Crit Mechanisms to Gen VI
Dogfish44 go ahead. As of dogfish's post in implementation, crit mechanics will be updated to gen 6
- HP
This will be brought up for discussion in a thread that is being prepared by the moderation team.
- Weight Moves
see above
- Rewards for Winning
reeeeally dislike this proposal but it merits discussion. Birkal, mind taking the lead on this one?
- Wish EN Formula
Received some opposition, some support. Discussion over formula and potential vote will occur. Discussion thread.
Also just as a heads up we'll be closing this thread in the next few days in lieu of a new thread that will take this one's place for a while, before opening mk 3 of this thread.
So if you've got any complicated proposals in the wings, best to sit on them for a bit.
Also <3 you Frosty, this was literally perfect.
Last edited:
Locking this thread. All "feedback" should be directed to the state of theg ame thread for now, a mark 3 thread will be constructed once the SotG has concluded.
- Status