I very briefly thought about making a post that summarizes what you’ve done this game, and putting that into context of your usual town meta and my evaluation of how effective you are as that alignment, in a polite tone but which belies some very nasty feelings towards you
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC Wikimafia, The Free Online Mafia [TOWN+BROIL WIN]
- Thread starter CaffeineBoost
- Start date
you thinking that cover is a bad thing is wild but ok you do you
you also don't have an effective meta read on me so why would you compare to any town meta which is proven incorrect anyways? idgi
why is the vote of celever again
His first content post is likely on tvt saying "oh there's mafia in this group" imo, without really saying why each individual is mafia it was just sweeping labelling because it looked like he felt he could sit back and poke the group.
But when I called him out he immediately recinded and said it was as bad post, but couldn't really say why he thought that he just kinda said it randomly so it feels like he wanted a pair of town to just die without even having a read on them. That being said hal is also a town lean for me now.
unvote...?
my reads on duskfall are all over the place
my reads on duskfall are all over the place
Idk, I think this is a disingenuous take bc I said I stopped reading on page 7 made a post talking v abstractly and then after asking for recaps acc read the thread and made a better post instead
Staying on me for the first bad post is p boring but w/e
you've not improved since though
and I don't see why saying "my brush stroke these are all mafia read" is townier based on the fact you didn't even know what was happening before you made it
Eh I think I’ve improved bc I’ve acc tried since in contrast to that initial post was a stream of consciousness without having read the thread but go off I guess
Idt trying is independently towny though mafia can try, I'm not trying to find the biggest tryhard player right, I'm trying to find mafia!
TBF this is what I tried to do and then everyone called me scum and didn't rlly catch me up and then Litt told me to read the thread so I did
P good advice tho
Yea I feel like you know you're misreading what I said. Thought put into posts > no thought put into posts and you're just saying my posts haven't improved without justifying that statement so
There's a difference between not caring (like Haruno), which I wish he would try a bit at least!
and not reading and trying to fabricate a read, then erasing it immediately after getting away with it right, one is not caring the other is trying to put contribution in but only so long as you dojt have to stand by it
Thought out into posts is far better and it helps town a lot more, but often times mafia put more thought into posts than town because they actually have something to hide. Obviously there is nuance but just because you are doing something thoughtful doesn't make you town
and not reading and trying to fabricate a read, then erasing it immediately after getting away with it right, one is not caring the other is trying to put contribution in but only so long as you dojt have to stand by it
Thought out into posts is far better and it helps town a lot more, but often times mafia put more thought into posts than town because they actually have something to hide. Obviously there is nuance but just because you are doing something thoughtful doesn't make you town
If you really had nothing to hide, you'd have made a better role claim such as claiming Unclesam! And your ability is to lead the village!!!! As for what ability that has ¯\_(ツ)_/¯.
After all a role like Unclesam would have nothing to hide and would be the perfect claim whether that be as scum or town!
After all a role like Unclesam would have nothing to hide and would be the perfect claim whether that be as scum or town!
All I'm saying is judge by posts that I put thought into and not smth I just threw out right after waking up to do something in-thread bc I literally hadn't read the room and was treating this like a casual game like last time and not this apparently high level serious game where you have to think
Tunnelling on me is boring but I get the vibe I won't like this game a great deal anyway so idm if you just ml me D1 before I become invested
it exists in thread and it showed your mindset to me
I don't think this game is any more high stakes than last time tbh and you still tryharded last time anyways right?
I'm not tunneling you, you've just done something pretty scummy and nothing towny to follow so far
please can we not do the D1 ate i want this to be a fun game not a personal ego feelings contest it's my first game back 
I didn't even have a mindset I hadn't read the thread yet idk what you're not getting about this
You literally hosted last game and saw that I was just throwing random stuff out to see what people did with it. That was obviously a bad playstyle but I was just doing that again before I deided to try
And I'm not saying this is higher stakes I'm saying it's higher quality gameplay. I tryharded last game bc it was my first time playing mafia in over a year or whenever that 11p Eli hosted was, and I tryharded Eli's game bc that had been my first time playing in several years outside of a hydra I played one day in. Last time was newbie-minded so I could tryhard in a casual way, this time there's clearly more skill involved so I'll prob acc post less but I'll put more thought into each one.Feels like a tunnel until you discuss later posts bc you're only evidencing the one. Other players have read the later posts as towny, why are they wrong?
Part of the reason why this game feels p uninvestable is bc there's a lot of "I am the greatest player in this game" from you and you're kinda just repeating reads into the collective conscience without justifying them tbh. Hal's doing it too but at least cased yours
"performative"